Monday, November 16, 2009

At Least I Held My Tongue


 While I was waiting in line to pick up my bountiful basket I encountered an interesting woman.  We were supposed to line up alphabetically.  Which meant I left the back of the line and moved forward quite a bit.  When I arrived at the front, the woman first in line an I began a conversation.  We were speculating why we were forced to wait outside well after the appointed time for pick-up.  If we are not on time then our food is donated to the local fire department.  So as we sat shivering we speculated why the doors were locked.  The subject of wild children came up.  She announced that children need to be trained to stay be their parents.  I agreed, but also suggested that a baby cannot be expected to not wander.  She then announced that she had worked at a crisis nursery for six years and knew all about wandering children.  I did not mention that I had also worked at a crisis nursery, and knew just as much as she about neglected children.  She suggested a leash; I countered that some children will not wear them.  She said that suggested a lack of training.  I said, "Yes, but they all come to earth with their own personalities."  Around and around we went; her implying that I was not a high quality parent because I let my children be children.  Good thing the doors opened before I lost it and was really rude.  We were both very polite and yet the feeling that I got from her was there are infinite ways to be a bad parent, but only one way to be a good one, hers.  I left feeling judged and felt sorry for her that she had no room for differences.
 So, speak up.  Are you a leash toting nazi, or do you let your kids' differences shine through as you gently teach them how to be the best they can be?

5 comments:

  1. I am defiently on the fence on this one. I belive there is a time and place for everything and children, who are at an age of reasonable understanding of course, should be taught that there are times where they need to be still and quiet. But I am like you Michelle.. how does a child learn the ways of life if they are never allowed to get out and explore it.
    I am learning through my first encounters into toddlerhood how embarresing they can be when they are "learning" but come on we all have these moments people relaxe and take a deep breath and enjoy them before they are gone!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have to agree that a leash is not for every child. We tried one for Elijah and he through a tissy fit. That is why we had to get the fence. There are a few times I had him ware the monkey on his back leash. Actually it was once. When we went hiking for the first time, so he wouldn't take a dive off the edge. The next time we went he was just fine to stay clear of the edges. So he was taught and learn, so no need for now.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that the whole point is that each child is different and if a leash can work with one, doesn't mean it will work for all.
    I have a couple children who I wish felt more comfortable to wander a bit in new situations, then I have a couple who need to be reined in more. What I definitely don't need is a strange second guessing my decisions as a parent!
    Way to hold your tongue. She doesn't sound like the type who was really interested in an open dialogue on parenting techniques.

    ReplyDelete
  4. annoying! I say you know your kids best! I hate it when strangers think they know better.

    ReplyDelete
  5. People can be SO close minded! Drew was a leashed child but she NEEDED it. She would run away from us and it got hard chasing her when I was huge and preggo with Brody. Drew liked the leash though. She liked the monkey on her back but Brody, wouldn't stand for it! Every child is different and not every child needs to be 'trained' on a leash. They are children not animals!

    ReplyDelete

thoughts on my thoughts